Increasing Success Rate of Rent to Own with Scott Ulmer

Scott Ulmer, a seasoned professional in the rent-to-own business, brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table. In this episode, host Dave Debeau delves into Scott's invaluable insights on increasing success rates in the rent-to-own sector. They explore strategies to utilize, potential challenges to address, and alternative methods to consider. 

Increasing Success Rate Of Rent To Own With Scott Ulmer

Scott Ulmer, a seasoned professional in the rent-to-own business, brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table. In this episode, host Dave Debeau delves into Scott’s invaluable insights on increasing success rates in the rent-to-own sector. They explore strategies to utilize, potential challenges to address, and alternative methods to consider. 

Scott started his journey in the rent-to-own market over two decades ago. His passion for solving problems in real estate led him to this promising niche. Scott believes the rent-to-own strategy can bring win-win results for homeowners and renters if applied correctly, offering an alternative path to home ownership. 

Over the years, Scott Ulmer witnessed various scenarios where traditional home-buying methods proved to be a roadblock for many aspiring homeowners. This motivated him to develop a system to help individuals overcome home ownership hurdles. The result was a well-oiled rent-to-own model that aimed to benefit all involved parties. 

Scott Ulmer found significant success in the rent-to-own industry through his innovative approach. He emphasizes that his success is not solely due to profit-making but also because of his capacity to give back to the community by assisting families in achieving their home ownership dreams. 

With such profound experience and success, Scott Ulmer has much wisdom to share. His advice to aspiring professionals venturing into the rent-to-own business focuses on understanding the ins and outs of the industry, keeping abreast of legal requirements, and, most importantly, maintaining a service-first approach.

But first, if you want financing for your next investment and want to know what type of collateral may be involved, click the link below for a free strategy call with our mortgage team at LendCity to discuss your specific situation.

Understanding the Basics of Rent-to-Own 

In this episode, Dave Debeau discusses the rent-to-own deal with industry specialist Scott Ulmer. They delve into the specifics of this real estate strategy, which often serves as a powerful tool for homeowners and renters. Dave and Scott discuss the basics of a rent-to-own agreement, which includes learning about the roles of the tenant-buyer and the investor-seller and the benefits each stands to gain. 

Tenant-buyer: This individual or family rents a property to buy it later. In a rent-to-own agreement, the tenant-buyer pays an upfront, non-refundable option fee. They also agree to rent the property for a set number of years before they have the option to buy. 

Investor-seller: The investor-seller owns the property in question. They agree to rent the property and give the tenant-buyer the right to buy it at a future date. The investor-seller receives the option fee and regular rent payments in return for this flexibility. 

A rent-to-own agreement rests on two key documents: the Option to Purchase Agreement and the Residential Lease. The option agreement outlines the tenant-buyer’s right to buy the property at a future date, including the agreed-upon purchase price. The lease agreement outlines the rental terms, including the rent amount and responsibility for maintenance and repairs.

Benefits of Rent-to-Own Properties 

Whether you’re a property owner looking for a reliable investment strategy or a potential homeowner struggling to secure a mortgage, rent-to-own properties provide opportunities for both parties. Scott Ulmer, an expert in this field, highlights the benefits of this arrangement: 

Security and Stability 

In rent-to-own agreements, the property owner benefits from steady, reliable income over the contract period, offering financial security. Simultaneously, potential homeowners benefit from the stability of remaining in the same home while they work towards ownership. It’s a win-win situation, Ulmer says. 

Achieving Homeownership 

For potential homeowners struggling with traditional financing methods, Ulmer emphasizes that rent-to-own offers a stepping stone to homeownership. It’s an opportunity to improve your financial situation, credit score, and saving ability while you’re gradually working toward buying. 


As Dave Debeau and Scott Ulmer discuss, rent-to-own contracts offer more flexibility than a traditional mortgage. The tenant-buyer can try out the property before fully committing, while the seller can sell if the buyer decides not to purchase. 

In sum, the benefits of rent-to-own properties are numerous. Property owners and potential homeowners can benefit by understanding these advantages and acting wisely.

Common Challenges in Rent-to-Own Deals 

In this episode of the podcast, Dave Debeau invites guest Scott Ulmer, an expert in Rent-to-Own housing, to delve into some common challenges individuals often encounter in rent-to-own agreements. 

Unexpected Repair and Maintenance Costs 

Firstly, Scott highlights one challenge many encounters: unexpected repair and maintenance costs. When you are a rent-to-own tenant, you become responsible for the upkeep of the property. Scott implies this significance by stating, “Anticipate these costs early on to prevent unexpected financial burdens.” 

Failure to Exercise the Purchase Option 

Scott also draws attention to another pitfall: the failure to exercise the purchase option. This happens when a tenant, for various reasons, can’t buy the property at the end of the agreement. Scott suggests that “having a proper financial plan can make a significant difference.” 

High Risk of Default 

Lastly, Dave and Scott discuss the high risk of default in rent-to-own transactions. If tenants fall behind on rent payments, they risk losing the property and any equity they’ve built. “To avoid this,” Scott advises, “tenants should be certain they can afford the rental payments before entering into a rent-to-own agreement.” 

In conclusion, navigating rent-to-own agreements can indeed present challenges. However, with sound advice from experts like Scott and proper planning, these obstacles can be mitigated to increase the success rate of rent-to-own.

Critical Factors for a Successful Rent-to-Own Agreement 

When host Dave Debeau sat down with guest Scott Ulmer, they dove into the critical factors for a triumphant rent-to-own agreement. Utilizing Scott Ulmer’s expertise, they identified elements that set an agreement up for success. Knowing these vital features is crucial before starting this potentially lucrative real estate journey. 

Thorough Tenant Screening 

One essential element Scott Ulmer emphasized is performing comprehensive tenant screenings. This practice allows you to make an informed decision about the potential tenant’s ability and commitment to fulfill the terms of the agreement. For instance, listing out their financials and work stability record can shed light on their capability to see through the rental term and option to purchase. 

Clear Communication and Documentation 

Scott Ulmer and Dave Debeau also highlighted the importance of straightforward communication and comprehensive documentation. You should convey the terms of the agreement clearly and ensure both parties understand them fully. This openness goes hand in hand with thorough documentation to keep a solid record of the arrangements. 

Clarifying Responsibilities 

In discussing responsibilities, Scott Ulmer affirmed that both parties must know their respective functions in the agreement. This might involve who will take care of maintenance and repairs or the implications of failing to exercise the option to buy. Ensuring clarity on these points can help avoid misunderstandings and disputes. 

Professional Guidance 

Finally, Scott reiterates the importance of professional guidance. A rent-to-own agreement can be complex and involve a multitude of legal details. Having a real estate attorney or experienced professional review the agreement before signing can help both parties to ensure the terms are fair and equitable. 

A successful rent-to-own agreement requires thorough tenant screening, clear communication, clarification of responsibilities, and professional guidance. Ensure you are well-familiar with these critical factors, as shared by Scott Ulmer, to increase your chances of a successful rent-to-own journey.

Maintaining and Managing Rent-to-Own Properties 

Managing a rent-to-own property is significantly different from traditional property management. In sharing his expert advice, Scott Ulmer emphasizes that a proactive and organized approach is essential for successful management. 

As with traditional rentals, managing rent-to-own properties involves collecting monthly payments and attending to maintenance requests. But it goes beyond that. 

  • Tenant education: It’s essential that the tenant-buyer fully understands the contract before agreeing. Scott advises that clear communication is fundamental in rent-to-own deals.
  • Maintenance responsibilities: One unique aspect of rent-to-own properties involves those responsible for repairs and maintenance. Often, landlords will pass on these responsibilities to the tenant-buyer.
  • Property evaluations: It’s essential to conduct regular check-ins and evaluations to ensure that the property is adequately cared for. Remember, unlike traditional rentals, the renter can buy the property at the end of the lease term.

Maintaining records is critically important in managing rent-to-own properties. According to Scott, an organized system of tracking payments and other communications can help avoid conflicts and misunderstandings down the line. Tools such as property management software or even simple spreadsheets can be utilized.

Lastly, Scott Ulmer also recommends being prepared for the possibility of the tenant defaulting on their monthly payments. It would be best to have a contingency plan for these scenarios, whether eviction, renegotiation of the contract, or even listing the property for a traditional sale or lease.

In Conclusion: Managing a rent-to-own property comes with its own set of challenges. However, with good communication, organization, and a clear understanding of your responsibilities, you can effectively manage such properties and increase your opportunities for a successful deal.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls in Rent-to-Own Transactions 

In this episode, Dave Debeau sits down with Scott Ulmer to discuss potential pitfalls in rent-to-own transactions and how to avoid them proactively—Ulmer shares key insights from his extensive experience garnered through years of work in the rent-to-own industry. 

Unrealistic Tenant Expectations 

Scott warns against the common pitfall of tenants’ unrealistic rent-to-own agreement expectations. The problem arises when tenants assume they would automatically qualify to purchase the house at the end of the lease term. Educating tenants on the requirements and expectations for a successful transition from renting to owning is crucial. 

Lack of Legal and Financial Counselling 

Scott emphasizes the importance of legal and financial consultations for the tenant and property owner. An expert’s guidance ensures all parties understand and agree to the terms, reducing potential legal conflicts. Both sides must realize that rent-to-own agreements have distinctive characteristics compared to other property transactions. 

Inadequate Market Research and Property Selection 

According to Ulmer, property selection is another area where pitfalls may occur. This typically happens when property owners or investors fail to conduct comprehensive market research. Knowing the location’s current market dynamics, including its future projection, is critical to the property’s long-term profitability. A poorly chosen property can lead to detrimental financial impacts. 

In conclusion, Dave Debeau and Scott Ulmer provide valuable insights on avoiding pitfalls in rent-to-own transactions. The goal is to enable a successful and profitable rent-to-own journey for tenants/buyers and property owners/investors. The rent-to-own process can be a win-win solution for everyone involved through education, professional guidance, market analysis, and strategic property selection.

Exploring Alternatives to Rent-to-Own 

In Dave Debeau’s conversation with Scott Ulmer, they dive into some alternatives to rent-to-own arrangements. Scott emphasizes that while rent-to-own may be a valuable path for many potential homeowners, knowing other options that suit different circumstances is essential. With his depth of experience in this market, Scott offers a wealth of insights on this topic. 

Lease-Purchase Agreements 

A lease-purchase agreement is an alternative arrangement similar to rent-to-own. In this setup, you agree to buy the property at the end of a specific lease term, usually one to three years. Unlike rent-to-own, the core distinction is that a lease-purchase agreement is legally binding. Scott Ulmer warns that this decision requires due diligence, as there is less flexibility in changing your mind. 

Owner Financing 

Scott also mentions owner financing as another viable option. In an owner financing arrangement, the property seller provides financing for the purchase, acting as a lender. This method can be a beneficial alternative for those struggling with conventional mortgage approval. According to Scott, the key is excellent communication and clear terms agreed upon by both parties. 

Housing Assistance Programs 

Scott Ulmer points out various federal, state, and local housing assistance programs are available. These programs often aim to aid lower-income households, veterans, or first-time homebuyers, offering loans with significantly lower interest rates and down payments. 

Scott reminds listeners, “It’s crucial not just to get into a house but to ensure you can afford to stay there.” Regardless of the path chosen, prospective homeowners should continuously pursue options that will provide the most secure and sustainable future.

If you are ready to start investing today and want more information about how your mortgage may be secured – or are looking to apply for a mortgage today – click the link below for a free strategy call with our mortgage team at LendCity today.

Listen To The Podcast