Investor Resources

What to Do When You Get A Low Appraisal On Your Rental Property?

What to Do When You Get A Low Appraisal On Your Rental Property
Download Investor Resources

Are you looking to sell your rental property after months, years, or even decades of holding it? Regardless of the strength of the local real estate market or the condition of your home, selling an asset for the correct price is a difficult task. Selling a home means jumping through institutional hoops, and navigating the market as a seller is much more complicated and time-consuming than navigating the market as a buyer.

Table of Contents - What to Do When You Get A Low Appraisal On Your Rental Property?

The fear that their properties would not ‘appraise out' is one of the most common concerns among real estate sellers. This signifies that the property's value has been determined to be less than the agreed-upon sale price by an independent real estate evaluator. As a result, institutional lenders are unable to issue mortgages worth more than the property's evaluated value.

It's a terrible predicament to be in, especially if you've already agreed to a deal with a potential buyer!

It can be frustrating to learn that your investment property isn't valued at the value you (and a buyer) believe it is worth after you've invested time and money into it. If you want to swiftly sell your investment for a profit, enhance your liquidity, or integrate your investments, things grow much more complicated.

Thankfully, you have options for disputing poor assessments or working with your buyer to sell your investment property for the agreed-upon amount. Even if it takes a little more effort, you may still get the best return on your investment property. Furthermore, resisting the evaluation will ensure that you maximise the value you've brought to your asset.


If you're looking save time, grow your net worth quickly and become a better investor without all the mistakes, using stocks & real estate as the vehicle for wealth, then click the learn more button to join our members only investing group where we show you our most profitable strategies and connect you with industry experts. FREE 14 day Risk-Free Trial.

Learn More


How to dispute the appraisal

When faced with a poor appraisal, the first and most critical step is to appeal or contest the appraiser's conclusion. Take care of this first!

Despite the fact that appraisers are independent real estate professionals, they may undervalue a property unintentionally. The majority of mistaken assessments are the result of basic, glaring mistakes. Here are several options for appealing your property's appraisal if you believe it was priced incorrectly:

Obtain a copy of the appraisal report

The first step is to obtain a copy of the appraisal report. The appraisal report will not be delivered to you immediately as a seller; in fact, you may have to request a copy from the buyer or their agent. Once you have access to it, check over it thoroughly and look for any potential problems. Look for obvious mistakes, such as improperly listed square footage or room numbers. Even the slightest mistake can slice thousands off your appraised price, so double-check everything!

Update your comparable rates

Appraisers use current real estate sales in your region to determine property values. For example, if a three-bedroom home down the street recently sold for $500,000, they'll utilise that information to determine the true value of your home. Appraisers may find it difficult to keep up with the latest sale patterns in a given area due to the fast-changing nature of the real estate industry. If you are ware of any local competitions, gather the most recent information to include with your application.

Highlight renovations and improvements

Let the appraiser know if you've made any significant upgrades or changes to your investment property. Everything from new construction to new windows to better landscaping could increase the asset's worth. If you've made a change that isn't reflected in the initial report, mention it. Appraisers cannot consider any unpermitted modifications in the updated value of their appraisals unless they have all necessary site improvement permits.

Get a second opinion

Hire your own appraiser to come out and inspect the property and give you a second view. Another appraiser who is more knowledgeable with the area may be able to give you a more accurate estimate of the true value of your investment property. Be careful, however, that the secondary appraiser's valuation may not be accepted by your buyer's lender. Most lenders rely on appraisers with whom they have long-standing contracts. Getting a second opinion is still a smart idea to acquire a more accurate estimate of your property's genuine value.

Collaboration with the buyer

If you've tried unsuccessfully to challenge the appraisal, you can still sell your investment property for the agreed-upon price. Your buyer will need to collaborate with you to come up with some other options.

If your buyer is serious about buying your home, they will most likely work with you to find a method to complete the transaction. The issue that is preventing them from succeeding is a lack of funding. When this issue is resolved, the sale can proceed.

Asking the buyer to make up the difference in cash is one strategy to overcome a low appraisal. While it may be difficult for some buyers to come up with enough extra cash to cover both the down payment and the deficit, if you are selling the home to another real estate investor, it may be doable.

If you are dealing with a motivated buyer who can not come up with the cash needed to make up the difference, consider carrying a second mortgage for them. You may lend them the money to cover the difference, with the understanding that they will pay the rest in instalments or all at once. You may also be able to collect a little bit of interest in this situation.

Of course, you may want to explore lowering the sale price of your real estate investment property to make it more accessible to potential buyers. Consider making concessions such as transferring closing costs to the buyer.

Knowing how to deal with inaccurate evaluations and work with potential buyers to overcome poor assessments can help you navigate the real estate market more effectively. You will be able to expedite your path to financial independence if you have the knowledge to make a profit on a property despite a poor assessment.

How to Handle a Low Appraisal as a Buyer


Interested in Rental Property Financing? If so, contact us and we will show you how you can buy unlimited rental properties with great rates.

Contact Us

This article was updated on
Download Investor Resources

You may also like: